England & Other International Games - October 2024
Moderators: Gnome, last.caress, Wilko1304, Rio, bristolhammerfc, the pink palermo, chalks
- Captain Corelli
- Posts: 582
- Joined: Thu Oct 08, 2020 11:55 am
- Has liked: 173 likes
- Total likes: 116 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
Carsley shouldn't be sacked for trying something new.
He SHOULD be sacked for dropping Bowen, though.
He SHOULD be sacked for dropping Bowen, though.
-
- Posts: 2939
- Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2010 7:41 pm
- Has liked: 1333 likes
- Total likes: 847 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
Was Carsley trying to replicate the Dutch “ total football” idea? The 2 cb’s and Rice apart we looked shapeless, too many trying to do the same thing, all floating about trying to be creative, and there was neither a striker or an identifiable “false 9”. Agree yesterday was ideal for experimentation, but there are key roles in any team and nobody seemed to know who was supposed to play them. All that attacking talent and hardly a shot on target, bit like a side selected in the playground.
- dodger
- Posts: 14743
- Joined: Fri Jul 11, 2003 12:16 pm
- Location: Scotland / London / Japan / somewhere in between the 3
- Has liked: 237 likes
- Total likes: 347 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
It's not about 'sacking' him - he doesn't have the job yet!Captain Corelli wrote: ↑Fri Oct 11, 2024 7:00 am Carsley shouldn't be sacked for trying something new.
He SHOULD be sacked for dropping Bowen, though.
Thought it was madness from the start that he was even being considered. Will be massively underwhelmed if he is the eventual appointment.
Re: England Games - October 2024
The issue for me was a weak spine of the team. Great goal line clearance from Colwell but apart from that him and Stones looked physically weak in central defence. Pavlidis should never have been allowed to take so many touches inside the box for his first goal. Then you only have Rice providing protecting ahead of them rather than a double pivot. Going with one CDM only works against weak opposition at international level. Greece are no mugs. Stones is not captain material IMO. Rice would have been a better choice.
If you're going to experiment then this is the game to do it in but it didn't work. Frontfoot football is great when it works and against weak opposition but it won't be long before the manager is labelled tactically naive (as Ange is finding out...mate). What I find interesting is how ordinary supposedly world beating players like Saka and Palmer look against teams like Greece, Denmark and Slovakia. Not saying they're not good players but the Premier League is so overhyped.
If you're going to experiment then this is the game to do it in but it didn't work. Frontfoot football is great when it works and against weak opposition but it won't be long before the manager is labelled tactically naive (as Ange is finding out...mate). What I find interesting is how ordinary supposedly world beating players like Saka and Palmer look against teams like Greece, Denmark and Slovakia. Not saying they're not good players but the Premier League is so overhyped.
- DusseldorfHammer
- Posts: 8038
- Joined: Sun May 30, 2021 8:34 am
- Has liked: 3708 likes
- Total likes: 3544 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
Why "madness"? He has worked with a large number of players from this group before. Who was available outside of maybe Poch? Not much to gain this season from getting the England job. Might be different in six months. Seems sensible from the FA to takre their time to make a deep analysis of the player pool and what type of candidates it requires to increase the chance of winning the WC title in 2026.
Re: England Games - October 2024
In this country, I feel we under value the non spectacular quiet and tidy midfielder who occupies spaces and plays it simple, keeping the ball rotating, supporting play. That was the role Angel Gomez had and I thought we looked better for it.
In no universe should Gordon, Saka, Palmer, Bellingham, and Foden be ever picked in the same team again.
I'd have a front three of Grealish, Kane/Watkins, and Bowen supported by Rice and Gomez.
In no universe should Gordon, Saka, Palmer, Bellingham, and Foden be ever picked in the same team again.
I'd have a front three of Grealish, Kane/Watkins, and Bowen supported by Rice and Gomez.
- ironilunga
- Posts: 9978
- Joined: Fri Jan 08, 2010 11:05 am
- Has liked: 477 likes
- Total likes: 1413 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
Nope, like the majority of England managers before him he was trying to shoehorn in the best England players available to him rather than the best players available for every given position. Tis why we will always be also rans until we employ a manager like Pep who is not too frightened to drop a big name.1895Hammer wrote: ↑Fri Oct 11, 2024 7:51 am Was Carsley trying to replicate the Dutch “ total football” idea?
-
- Posts: 392
- Joined: Sun Aug 18, 2024 1:52 pm
- Has liked: 208 likes
- Total likes: 108 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
England fans remind me of Arsenal fans - deluded.
Everyone in the Euros wanted all our best attacking talent on the pitch and wanted a less pragmatic approach.
Southgate leaves, the new guy does exactly what the fans were deriding Southgate for not having the “bottle” to do and one bad result in a friendly and everyone is saying he’s clueless
Everyone in the Euros wanted all our best attacking talent on the pitch and wanted a less pragmatic approach.
Southgate leaves, the new guy does exactly what the fans were deriding Southgate for not having the “bottle” to do and one bad result in a friendly and everyone is saying he’s clueless
- pablo jaye
- Posts: 11887
- Joined: Fri Mar 11, 2005 6:08 pm
- Location: Somewhere massive!
- Has liked: 2926 likes
- Total likes: 1134 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
On reflection, now that I am free of the scrum and hustle and bustle of London, the Greeks definitely deserved to win the game, they had more drive and came at the England defence forcing us onto the back foot and into making errors. They knew that our CBS were prone if faced with a bit more aggression, whilst Pickford does tend to flap at times (admittedly I’m not a great fan of his).
In terms of the positives, I thought Gordon had a reasonable game and Watkins should have been on from the start. Palmer started OK but faded but the likes of Foden and Saka just didn’t get into gear. Too much tippy-tally stuff by England, hoping the Greeks would make and error, rather than being a bit more direct and aggressive, like they were … and won.
As for the atmosphere (aside from the excellent Greek fans) … the LS is more electric, so that’s saying something!!!
In terms of the positives, I thought Gordon had a reasonable game and Watkins should have been on from the start. Palmer started OK but faded but the likes of Foden and Saka just didn’t get into gear. Too much tippy-tally stuff by England, hoping the Greeks would make and error, rather than being a bit more direct and aggressive, like they were … and won.
As for the atmosphere (aside from the excellent Greek fans) … the LS is more electric, so that’s saying something!!!
- OFT
- Posts: 23822
- Joined: Mon Apr 04, 2005 11:59 pm
- Location: Sleepin’ in a bayou on a old rotten cot
- Has liked: 4133 likes
- Total likes: 2343 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
In my universe Gordon would never be picked again...for any team, the snidey cheating twat him.
- vietnammer
- Bucky the beaver
- Posts: 32797
- Joined: Sun Dec 08, 2002 2:31 am
- Location: Those little golden birdies look at them
- Has liked: 847 likes
- Total likes: 748 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
The 'human condition' of any football fan though ain't it!Nobles_combover wrote: ↑Fri Oct 11, 2024 8:55 am England fans remind me of Arsenal fans - deluded.
Everyone in the Euros wanted all our best attacking talent on the pitch and wanted a less pragmatic approach.
Southgate leaves, the new guy does exactly what the fans were deriding Southgate for not having the “bottle” to do and one bad result in a friendly and everyone is saying he’s clueless
- MD_HM
- Posts: 7877
- Joined: Thu Nov 16, 2006 11:00 am
- Location: London
- Has liked: 37 likes
- Total likes: 340 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
This 100%ironilunga wrote: ↑Fri Oct 11, 2024 8:43 am Nope, like the majority of England managers before him he was trying to shoehorn in the best England players available to him rather than the best players available for every given position. Tis why we will always be also rans until we employ a manager like Pep who is not too frightened to drop a big name.
Foden, Palmer and Bellingham are all CAMs this is the problem.
We don't have an obvious left winger but then have media darling Saka as a right winger.
So you need a team with CAMs supporting a striker and drop Saka or pick one of the three and play wingers (Saka and one of Gordon or Grealish)
But like Southgate before him they opt for the players not the team
- hammers92
- Posts: 13283
- Joined: Fri Mar 22, 2013 10:42 pm
- Has liked: 260 likes
- Total likes: 1917 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
Some of the hate Saka gets on here is bizarre. One of the best players in the league imo.
-
- Posts: 10651
- Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2019 10:38 am
- Has liked: 2956 likes
- Total likes: 2047 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
:
Imo that would have included an in form CF.
Instead he has tried to shoehorn in Foden, Palmer and Bellingham centrally at the expense of a CF.
It's an experiment, it was wrong (imo) and that's fine.
But imo it is the same issue as Southgate, names rather than balance and fit.
I thought most England fans wanted to see the most balanced team possible rather than trying to fit in all big names.Nobles_combover wrote: ↑Fri Oct 11, 2024 8:55 am England fans remind me of Arsenal fans - deluded.
Everyone in the Euros wanted all our best attacking talent on the pitch and wanted a less pragmatic approach.
Southgate leaves, the new guy does exactly what the fans were deriding Southgate for not having the “bottle” to do and one bad result in a friendly and everyone is saying he’s clueless
Imo that would have included an in form CF.
Instead he has tried to shoehorn in Foden, Palmer and Bellingham centrally at the expense of a CF.
It's an experiment, it was wrong (imo) and that's fine.
But imo it is the same issue as Southgate, names rather than balance and fit.
- jastons
- Posts: 13396
- Joined: Fri May 07, 2004 7:23 am
- Location: Here
- Has liked: 1043 likes
- Total likes: 906 likes
- Metal Hammer
- Posts: 6884
- Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2005 2:28 pm
- Location: The Beast from the East is Rising
- Has liked: 1445 likes
- Total likes: 1293 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
Doesn't leave mushroom for error?vietnammer wrote: ↑Fri Oct 11, 2024 5:32 am "Maybe this is what happens when you play all the fun guys" (David Hytner, Guardian)
- hammers92
- Posts: 13283
- Joined: Fri Mar 22, 2013 10:42 pm
- Has liked: 260 likes
- Total likes: 1917 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
Yep, stand by it 100%. Sake has delivered in an England shirt, Foden never has.
- DusseldorfHammer
- Posts: 8038
- Joined: Sun May 30, 2021 8:34 am
- Has liked: 3708 likes
- Total likes: 3544 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
Also pretty ridiculous, that a new England manager/coach isn't allowed to try something new or make mistakes in games that won't matter anything in a year from now.
- vietnammer
- Bucky the beaver
- Posts: 32797
- Joined: Sun Dec 08, 2002 2:31 am
- Location: Those little golden birdies look at them
- Has liked: 847 likes
- Total likes: 748 likes
- ironilunga
- Posts: 9978
- Joined: Fri Jan 08, 2010 11:05 am
- Has liked: 477 likes
- Total likes: 1413 likes
Re: England Games - October 2024
I think Carsley has made himself look a bit daft.DusseldorfHammer wrote: ↑Fri Oct 11, 2024 9:16 am Also pretty ridiculous, that a new England manager/coach isn't allowed to try something new or make mistakes in games that won't matter anything in a year from now.
What message does it give to Solanke and Watkins that when Kane is out the manager elects not to play a striker? I mean, Im assuming Kane would have played if fit, so it’s not about a change in system…..rookie error.